> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://gijustice.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Motion for Leave to Amend (ECF 53)
- URL: https://gijustice.com/20261120-manning-ecf53/
- Published: 2026-11-21T02:00:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-21T05:23:47.000Z
- Author: Logan M Isaac
- Tags: 6-25-CV-01159-MC, James Manning, Nakeia Daniels, Shelly Boshart Davis, Renee Perry, Brett Hanes, ODVA, LAC

**PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE THIRD AMENDED COMPLAINT (Fed. R. Civ. P. 15(a)(2), 16(b)(4))**

### LR 7-1(a) CERTIFICATION

Plaintiff certifies that on November 6, 2026, he sent counsel for the State Defendants (Tracy I. White, Rebecca R. Chapman) written notice of this motion under the subject line "Notice of Intent to Move for Leave to Amend – LR 7-1(a) Conferral." The notice identified each proposed change, the grounds, and the Bates-numbered materials relied on, offered a telephone conference, and asked for the State's position by November 10, 2026\. Ms. White responded the same day with questions on the scope of the amendment, and Plaintiff answered each in writing. On November 20, 2026, Plaintiff sent another email with updated details and the State responded “We oppose all.” without offering its reasoning. 

## MOTION

Plaintiff moves for leave to file the attached Third Amended Complaint (Ex. A) to: (1) name **Brett Hanes** in place of Doe 1 (Capitol access restriction); (2) add **Nakeia Daniels** (ODVA) for her December 2024 referral to the Oregon State Police; and (3) add **James Manning** in his administrative capacity only, for non-legislative conduct. Plaintiff does not re-plead the legislative acts dismissed in ECF 14 as a basis for liability. If the Court finds the Manning claim improper, Plaintiff asks that it be severed or dismissed without affecting the other claims. Fed. R. Civ. P. 21.

## **BACKGROUND**

1. ECF 14 (Jan. 22, 2026) dismissed Manning on legislative-immunity grounds as to the SB 1057/SJM 1 scheduling act. It held that claims against Davis, Perry and the Doe defendants (including Hanes) were minimally sufficient. ECF 14 at 6–7.
2. Defendants' document production of November 4, 2026, was the first time Plaintiff learned of the January 24, 2025 Rancik/Brainard communication. ISAAC-LAC-SDT-000491.
3. Daniels's role first appeared in ISAAC-LAC-SDT-000249 and in Plaintiff’s Deposition given November 5, 2026\.
4. After the November 4 production, Plaintiff asked the State for the underlying 000491 communication. On November 20, the State told him it does not have it and believes it was a Teams message that was not retained. Ex. B.
5. Plaintiff gave notice of this motion on November 6, 2026, less than 48 hours after the production, and files it on November 20, 2026.

## LEGAL STANDARD

Leave to amend is freely given when justice so requires. Fed. R. Civ. P. 15(a)(2). Because the pretrial schedule has passed, Plaintiff must also show good cause under Rule 16(b)(4). The focus is on the movant's diligence, which in this case involves a pro se Plaintiff with exceedingly limited time for detailed processing of large discovery files. *Johnson v. Mammoth Recreations, Inc.*, 975 F.2d 604, 609 (9th Cir. 1992). If good cause exists, Rule 15 applies, and the Court considers bad faith, undue delay, prejudice, futility and prior amendments. *Foman v. Davis*, 371 U.S. 178, 182 (1962); *Eminence Capital, LLC v. Aspeon, Inc.*, 316 F.3d 1048, 1052 (9th Cir. 2003). 

## ARGUMENT

### A. Good cause. 

Plaintiff could not have pleaded these claims earlier. The facts supporting the Manning and Daniels claims appeared in the State's November 4 production and in the November 5 testimony. Plaintiff gave notice within two days, and the motion followed within \[14\] days. He is pro se and had not planned to add any Does until the facts related to Manning and Hanes were disclosed in ISAAC-LAC-SDT-000491\. After his Deposition by the State, Plaintiff did another, more detailed search on Daniels and determined the parallel conduct was identical to Perry and, on information and belief, he believes there may be evidence of Conspiracy between Daniels, Manning, and other Does. 

### B. No undue delay, bad faith, or repeated failure. 

The State's own late production, and its inability to produce the 000491 communication, explain the timing. The First and Second Amended Complaints (Sept. 24 and Dec. 9, 2025) preceded any of this evidence.

### C. No prejudice. 

The amendment adds no new theory of liability against the existing defendants beyond Hanes, who was already pleaded as Doe 1 in the same Capitol-restriction claim. The Davis deposition is already set for December 15, 2026, and summary judgment briefing has been extended by agreement to January 15, 2027\. ECF 52\. The new defendants can be served and respond on a schedule that does not disturb the existing claims. Claims II and III stand independently, so severance under Rule 21 protects existing defendants if the Court prefers.

### D. Not futile. 

Claim II rests only on non-legislative acts: the December 10, 2024 report to OSP and the January 27, 2025 alarm. ECF 14 treated the scheduling decision as legislative and said motive is irrelevant, but it did not address those acts. *Bogan v. Scott-Harris*, 523 U.S. 44, 54–55 (1998) (the test looks at the nature of the act). The scheduling decisions are pleaded as background only, and Plaintiff preserves his position on ECF 14 for appeal. 

### E. Limitations make denial costly. 

The two-year period for § 1983 claims runs on the Daniels act on December 4, 2026 and on the Manning act on December 10, 2026\. ORS 12.110(1). A denial after those dates would end these claims. Plaintiff asks for a ruling, or at least an order allowing the pleading to be filed, before December 4, 2026\. 

## CONCLUSION

Plaintiff asks the Court to grant leave to file the attached Third Amended Complaint (Ex. A), deem it filed, set a service and response schedule for the new defendants, and, in the alternative, sever Claims II and III under Rule 21.

---

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/62/5e/625e8b30-aba8-4ca4-b679-851550ded791/content/images/2026/11/20261120-ECF-53-Motion-for-Leave-to-Amend_Page_1.jpg)

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/62/5e/625e8b30-aba8-4ca4-b679-851550ded791/content/images/2026/11/20261120-ECF-53-Motion-for-Leave-to-Amend_Page_2.jpg)

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/62/5e/625e8b30-aba8-4ca4-b679-851550ded791/content/images/2026/11/20261120-ECF-53-Motion-for-Leave-to-Amend_Page_4.jpg)

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/62/5e/625e8b30-aba8-4ca4-b679-851550ded791/content/images/2026/11/20261120-ECF-53-Motion-for-Leave-to-Amend_Page_5.jpg)

The Court headers don't match my footers because I included an extra page scan by mistake...