LAC Objections to Subpoena
Included as Exhibit C in Plaintiff's Motion to Compel (ECF 40).
General Objections
- Objection to responding by June 18 as an unreasonably short response time.
- Objection to producing any documents or information that encroaches on the attorney-client privilege, is work product of State Defendants' or LAC's attorneys or other representatives, is material prepared in anticipation of litigation, or is a public record protected by ORS 192.345 and ORS 192.355.
- Objection to producing any confidential or personally identifiable information, including that protected by HIPAA or other confidentiality laws. Such information will be redacted or withheld.
- Objection to producing information that may pose a security risk. Such information will be redacted or withheld.
- Objection to requests for documents using broad terms, including but not limited to "concerning," "involving," "relating to," "all communications," and "all records" as ambiguous and unduly broad and burdensome.
- Objection to producing unduly broad or marginally relevant documents as placing an undue burden on LAC. LAC will produce only those responsive documents reasonably known to it to concern the allegations of the complaint (as limited by the Court's orders), reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence, and reasonably available.
- Objection to the definition of "footage" to include all metadata as unreasonably broad and burdensome. Objection to the same definition requiring production in "native digital format" as unnecessarily restrictive. Materials will be produced in a reasonably usable form.
- Objection to the definition of "Access Restrictions" to include "any related or predecessor restrictions" as insufficiently defined and unreasonably broad. LAC will use the term to include only those restrictions imposed by Representative Shelly Boshart Davis on February 7, 2025, and by Brett Hanes on February 21, 2025.
- Objection to the definition of "Defendants" because it incorrectly includes Senator Manning.
- Objection to producing responsive materials in native format with metadata intact as unreasonably broad and burdensome and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Materials will be produced in a reasonably usable form.
- Objection to producing electronically stored information that is not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost.
- Objection to description of privilege log to the extent it is beyond the scope of the FRCPs. LAC will produce a privilege log that complies with the FRCPs.
- Objection to producing items regarding any events on December 10, 2024, as that date is not part of the operative complaint and therefore is not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.
- Objection as overly broad and burdensome and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence to the extent the requested items go beyond the events involving Plaintiff at the Capitol on January 27, 2025, and the access restrictions.
- Objection to the instruction to provide information about documents or materials that no longer exists as overly broad, unduly burdensome, and inconsistent with the FRCPs. No such information will be provided.
- Objection to producing documents created after the date this lawsuit was filed as overly broad and burdensome.
Objections to specific items
- Item 1: Objection as unduly broad and burdensome in requesting "all footage" and footage from "any area of the Capitol." Subject to these objections, LAC does not have responsive records.
- Item 2: Objection as requesting items not retained by LAC. No responsive records exist.
- Item 3: Objection as overly broad and seeking documents not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Additionally, LAC incorporates its objections to Items 1 and 2, above.
- Item 4: Objection as overly broad and burdensome and seeking documents not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.
- Item 5: Objection as overly broad and burdensome and seeking documents not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Additional objection to producing any documents or information that encroaches on the attorney-client privilege, is work product of State Defendants' or LAC's attorneys or other representatives, or is material prepared in anticipation of litigation.
- Item 6: Objection as unreasonably broad and burdensome. LAC will only produce known reports regarding Plaintiff at the Capitol on the January 27, 2025.
- Item 8: Objection as unreasonably broad and burdensome and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence to the extent the requested items go beyond the events of January 27, 2025, and the access restrictions. These objections also apply to any communications with or regarding Senator Manning, as he has been removed from the case by Court Order. Additional objection to producing any documents or information that encroaches on the attorney-client privilege, is work product of State Defendants' or LAC's attorneys or other representatives, or is material prepared in anticipation of litigation; this objection includes the request for communications with Oregon Department of Justice attorneys.
- Item 9: Objection as overly broad and burdensome to the extent the request is not limited in time to the dates following the access restriction letters to the time the restrictions were lifted. Subject to these objections, no such documents exist.
- Item 10: Objection as overly broad and burdensome, as impinging on the security of the Capitol, and as not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Plaintiff is invited to view the citizen engagement map, here: Citizen Engagement Capitol Maps
- Item 11. Objection as overly broad and burdensome to the extent it seeks documents beyond those concerning the January 27 visit and the access restrictions.


